
A penalty can finish in the net and still need to be taken again. Another can be saved after players enter the area early, with no retake ordered. To understand the decision, identify who offended, whether their action mattered and what happened to the original kick.
This Asiabet33 football explainer follows the 2026/27 Laws of the Game, checked on 13 October 2026. It covers ordinary penalty kicks and the important difference when an accidental double touch happens during a shoot-out. The referee must assess the complete incident, so a single freeze-frame rarely answers every question.
The kicker must be identified and the ball stationary on the penalty mark. Other players, except the goalkeeper, must remain outside the penalty area, behind the mark and at least 9.15 metres away. The penalty arc helps mark that distance.
At the moment of the kick, at least part of one goalkeeper foot must be touching, in line with or behind the goal line. The ball must travel forward and becomes live when kicked and clearly moving. These requirements appear in the 2026/27 penalty-kick law.
Encroachment means entering a restricted position too soon. IFAB Law 14 applies an impact test to team-mates who do this.
An attacking player’s early movement is penalised if it clearly affects the goalkeeper, or if that player subsequently plays or challenges for the ball and scores, attempts to score or creates a scoring opportunity. A defending player’s early movement is penalised if it clearly affects the kicker, or their subsequent involvement prevents such an opportunity.
For an ordinary encroachment offence, apply this short guide:
If the goalkeeper breaches the line requirement and saves the penalty, the kick is retaken. If the ball goes in, the goal stands. If it misses or strikes the goal frame, a retake requires the goalkeeper’s offence to have clearly affected the kicker.
A goalkeeper whose offence causes a retake receives a warning for the first such offence in the game, then a caution for a further offence. The official summary table separates these outcomes. Seeing a goalkeeper move forward is therefore the beginning of the analysis: the timing, foot position and kick’s outcome still matter.
The 2026/27 law changes incorporate the clarification for a player who accidentally kicks with both feet together, or whose non-kicking foot or leg touches the ball immediately after the kick.
If that kick enters the goal, it is retaken. If it does not enter and the goalkeeper has committed no offence, the ordinary match restart is an indirect free kick to the defending team, with advantage available where appropriate. A goalkeeper offence can instead require a retake. This is a specific accidental contact rule. It does not give the kicker permission to deliberately play the ball again before another player touches it.
A shoot-out takes place after the match has ended. Under Law 10, the same accidental two-foot or immediate non-kicking-leg contact produces a retake if the ball enters the goal. If it does not, the attempt is recorded as missed, assuming no other offence changes the decision.
There is no open-play rebound for the kicker to chase. This is why a clip needs to identify whether the penalty occurred during the match or in the shoot-out. “Double touch” alone leaves out information needed to describe the outcome accurately.
The 2026/27 changes remove the blanket automatic caution for a kicker simply because the kicker and goalkeeper offend together. Particular offences still carry their own consequences. Illegal feinting after the run-up is complete, for example, brings an indirect free kick and a caution during the match.
Feinting during the run-up is permitted. Before calling a pause illegal, establish when it happened. Where several actions overlap, identify each one rather than assuming that the offences cancel out or that every combination must produce another kick.
Replay the incident in sequence. First locate the instant the ball is kicked. Then check the goalkeeper and the players outside the area. Follow the ball through the save, miss or goal, and keep watching anyone who becomes involved in a rebound.
Write a short description using observable details: “The defender entered early and cleared the rebound,” for example, is more useful than “Everyone moved.” If the camera hides the contact or a player’s position, leave that point unresolved until a clearer angle or official explanation is available.
For more football explainers, visit the Asiabet33 blog. Use the current competition rules and IFAB edition when checking an older incident, because a decision from a previous season may have been made under different wording.